Proof of consent cannot be given when one is intoxicated

That was the issue before the High Court on Friday when it heard the appeal of convicted rapist Ong Ming Wee, 29, who is fighting his conviction and sentence of seven years’ jail and eight strokes of the cane for rape.
He had failed to convince a district court during the trial last year that the woman had consented to having sex hours after they met at Zouk disco in 2009.

On Friday, his lawyer Subhas Anandan argued that the woman, who cannot be named, had consented to sex.

Mr Anandan pointed out that surveillance footage in the club showed that she had danced very closely to his client, who felt that she was trying to seduce him.

The lawyer said the pair had kissed during the taxi ride back to Ong’s Toa Payoh flat after leaving the club. Mr Anandan said she was crying rape only because Ong threw her out after they had sex and she was angry at being treated as a tool.

He added that Ong – who helps run a family-owned mini-mart in Toa Payoh North – did not use violence or any weapon against the woman.

But Deputy Public Prosecutor Leong Wing Tuck pointed out that the rape took place more than two hours after the dancing and there was a ‘cooling-off period’.

While Ong had not used physical violence or threatened her explicitly, he was in a position of dominance over the woman, who was intoxicated, said the DPP.

The DPP pointed out that Ong had told her that he would allow her to make a phone call to her mother if she had sex with him; this showed he was in control.

The DPP said the woman’s mindset was that of a ‘trapped animal’ and that she was ‘overawed into submitting’ to Ong.

Justice Quentin Loh reserved judgment.

However, he told both sides to make written submissions on a provision in the Penal Code which states that a person has not committed an offence if he had acted in mistaken belief.

——————————————————————————
Proof of consent cannot be given when one is intoxicated
Men you better stay away from woman who are intoxicated, because proof of consent cannot be given when one is intoxicated, even when there is no violence, but when she cries rape, you will be put behind bars, although the severity is not as heavy as when violence is used. You have better stay away from woman who are in this category, it is not worth while to be implicated lusting for sour grapes that will bring judgement on you. The verdict would seem to be heavy from the point no violence was used, and no force was used to bring her to his place, it could be amended to a charge of taking advantage of an intoxicated person instead of rape, where normally violence is used without consent. He has demanded sex and threatened to withdraw a phone call, that could confirm his intentions but it still requires the woman to consent, which she did in not in the right state of mind.
– Contributed by Oogle.

Advertisements

Author: Gilbert Tan TS

IT expert with more than 20 years experience in Apple, Andriod and Windows PC. Interests include hardware and software, Internet and multimedia. An experienced Real Estate agent, Insurance agent, and a Futures trader.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s